All-Time Captains
| YEAR | TEAM CAPTAIN(S) |
| 1890 | Amos Alonzo Stagg |
| 1891 | Amos Alonzo Stagg |
| 1892 | James Naismith |
| 1893 | Pierson S. Page |
| 1894 | Lawrence S. Oller |
| 1895 | Not Available |
| 1896 | Alanson L. Fish |
| 1897 | Alanson L. Fish |
| 1898 | Alanson L. Fish |
| 1899 | Alanson L. Fish |
| 1900 | George A. Cornell |
| 1901 | George A. Cornell |
| 1902 | Fred F. Bugbee |
| 1903 | J. Harry Gray |
| 1904 | Dexter W. Draper |
| 1905 | Appleton A. Mason |
| 1906 | Joseph S. Wright |
| 1907 | Fred L. Honhart |
| 1908 | William N. Howard |
| 1909 | Joseph H. McCullock |
| 1910 | Robert J. Delahanty |
| 1911 | Cuvier A. Metzler |
| 1912 | Daniel J. Kelly |
| 1913 | Frederick W. Dickens |
| 1914 | Walter W. Bell |
| 1915 | George A. Cooper |
| 1916 | Raymond R. Sermon |
| 1917 | Harold Drew |
| 1918 | Milton R. Johnson |
| 1919 | Percy H. Quinlan |
| 1920 | Chalres C. Cowell |
| 1921 | Leonard A. Watters |
| 1922 | Frank G. Civiletto |
| 1923 | Warren W. Watters |
| 1924 | John B. Stoeber |
| 1925 | Robert G. Elliott |
| 1926 | J. Kenneth Hafner |
| 1927 | Chester A. Bollier |
| 1928 | Edward J. Williamson |
| 1929 | Robert Hammond |
| 1930 | Harry C. Thompson |
| 1931 | Henry Knowlton |
| 1932 | Robert Brown |
| 1933 | Joseph Shields |
| 1934 | Lancelot Cooper |
| 1935 | Charles McGiven |
| 1936 | Warren Huston |
| 1937 | Harold Hall |
| 1938 | Roger Clark |
| 1939 | Richard Redding |
| 1940 | Donald J. Grant |
| 1941 | Karl Kurth, Paul Rose |
| 1942 | Robert Sturges |
| 1943 | No Team |
| 1944 | No Team |
| 1945 | No Team |
| 1946 | Jack Oelkers, Carl Coe |
| 1947 | Fred Booth, Fern Tetreau |
| 1948 | Bill Ward, Ed Stoeckel |
| 1949 | John Coons, Ed Mason |
| 1950 | Nate Osur, Bob D'Agostino |
| 1951 | Mort Meltzer, Joe Lettera |
| 1952 | Jack Etter, Paul Ryan |
| 1953 | Alex Sotir, Frank Truechet |
| 1954 | Ted Connor, John Leroy |
| 1955 | Ron Rouleau, Harold Kenyon |
| 1956 | George Benedict |
| 1957 | Dick MacPherson, Dick Shields |
| 1958 | Gary Golden, Ed Taylor |
| 1959 | Brant Wintersteen |
| 1960 | Cliff Heinze, Clifton Rubicam |
| 1961 | Don Ruggeri, Ron Coleman |
| 1962 | John Chester |
| 1963 | Robert Cobb |
| 1964 | Richard Fordyce |
| 1965 | Gary Wilcox, Scott Taylor |
| 1966 | Dave Bennett, Dave Hughes |
| 1967 | Paul Tierney, Bob Tousignant |
| 1968 | Al Cece, Dick Dobbert |
| 1969 | Bill Horgan, Don Dellostritto |
| 1970 | Bernie Barboza, Emil Pauli |
| 1971 | Wayne Sanborn, Robert Liljedahl |
| 1972 | Jim Woodward, John Mason |
| 1973 | Joe Kacevich, Chris Brown, Rich Lewis |
| 1974 | Jack Levy, Brian Crudden |
| 1975 | Ken Mitchell, Tom McCabe |
| 1976 | Roy Samuelsen, Kevin Monahan |
| 1977 | Bob Weller, Bob Groat |
| 1978 | Pete Watson, Jim Coale |
| 1979 | Jack Quinn |
| 1980 | Doug McKenney |
| 1981 | Jim Collis, John Richardson |
| 1982 | Scott Bird, Rich Mannello, Lou Paolillo |
| 1983 | Brian Ekblom, Ed Meacham, Tim Murphy |
| 1984 | Wally Case, John Gallo, Phil Laughlin |
| 1985 | Jim Anderson, Keith Robichaud, Bob Squires |
| 1986 | Jim D'Antuono, Bill Delaney, Steve Smith |
| 1987 | Kyle Caffrey, Bill Pacitto, Randy Turer |
| 1988 | Andy Bellagamba, Kyle Caffrey, Mike Fair, Skip Hanson |
| 1989 | Scott Fry, Kevin Norman, Tariff Waters |
| 1990 | Dennis Green, Eric Hackendorf, Kevin Handzel, Tariff Waters |
| 1991 | Rich Gray, Kevin Handzel, Fran Papasedero |
| 1992 | Lance Bacigalupo, Mike Cerasuolo |
| 1993 | Sean Finucane, John Griffith, Keith Sweeney |
| 1994 | John Griffith, A.J. Reilly, Tony Trisciani, Matt Way |
| 1995 | Jason Cashton, Jamie McGourty, Tony Trisciani |
| 1996 | Eric Ciano, Jamie McGourty |
| 1997 | Mark Doherty, Gary Malisos, Shawn Tarpey |
| 1998 | John Cena, Mike Fanning, Kevin Jordan |
| 1999 | Tim Hanley, Joe White |
| 2000 | Kevin Cahill, Tim Hanley, Tom Ryan |
| 2001 | Jason Perkins, Bob Sedlor, Kevin Vacca |
| 2002 | Jesse Baker, Andrew MacFadyen |
| 2003 | Jesse Baker, Ryan Santo, Jason McDonald, Farrand Violette |
| 2004 | Ryan Sylvia, Justin Fletcher |
| 2005 | Mike Grendal, Andrew Madigan, James McCarthy |
| 2006 | Adam Feit, Kevin Fessette, Andrew Madigan, Chris Sharpe |
| 2007 | Chris Sharpe, Joe Harasymiak, Brian Hess, Nate Germain |
| 2008 | Tom Caporale, Greg Webster, Andrew Jackson |
| 2009 | Greg Webster, Cody Flanigan |
| 2010 | John Carlson, Cody Flanigan, Joe Myhren |
| 2011 | James Kikel, Sean Meagher, Matt Ramos, Mark Safer |
| 2012 | Duke Ekblom, Mike MacDonald |
| 2013 | Max Nacewicz, Mike MacDonald, Sam Weiss, Scott Leech, Brodie Quinn |
| 2014 | Max Nacewicz, Jordan D'Onofrio, Mike Serricchio, Mike Dublin, Dan Macalena |
| 2015 | Max Nacewicz, Joey Racioppi, Keith Rodman, Andrew Savenelli, Mike Dublin |
| 2016 | Cody Brown, Nick Campbell, Nick Welsh, Christian Zotti |
| 2017 | Chris Hayden, Tyler Hyde, Dominic Traversa, Christian Zotti |
| 2018 | Brennan Fleming, Nick Giorgio, Marlowe Scott, Josh Thomas |
| 2019 | Nick Bainter, Jack Pavelchak, AJ Smith, David Mikos |